A series of very plain talks on very practical politic s by george washington plunkitt, recorded by william l. Plunkitt, who would hold court at the bootblack stand at the new york county courthouse, telling anyone who would listen about the difference between honest and dishonest. For plunkitt, the issue of being in the political world was more than just having the superior say to it. He lists several examples of the differences, such as the fact that the philadelphia gang runs up against the penal code.
Tammany hall political machine ran nyc in the 1800s. It became synonymous with bigcity government corruption during the period of its rule by boss william m. Plunkitt of tammany hall essay plunkitt of tammany hall 1. George washington plunkitt plunkitt of tammany hall the book. Although he was well known in new york city political circles in the latenineteenth and earlytwentieth centuries, his enduring fame came from a very short book with a very long subtitle. Tammany hall was a political force in new york city from its 1789 inception as a benevolent association to mayoral campaigns in the 1950s. Plunkitt became a power broker within tammany hall, and for nearly 40 years was the undisputed boss of the 15th assembly district, a heavily irish bastion on manhattans west side. Frequently its leadership was identical to the executive.
Analysis of plunkitt of tammany hall william bryce history 2 austin community college november 30, 2011 the purpose of this book report is to analyze the themes in plunkitt of tammany hall by william l. Plunkitts arguments against civil service reforms in. His time in politics coincided with the era of boss tweed, and later richard croker. Tammany hall, or simply tammany, was the name given to a powerful political machine that essentially ran new york city throughout much of the 19th century. Dec 09, 2015 plunkitt goes on to say that tammany hall is a great big machine, with each part adjusted delicate to do its job. What did tammany hall precinct captain plunkitt expect in return for providing such help for people. The book plunkitt of tammany hall is not only a monument to george w. Does george plunkitt consider the tammany district leader to be off from politics ever. Plunkitt, tammany leader of the fifteenth assembly district, sachem of the tammany society and chairman of the elections committee of tammany hall, who has held the offices of state senator, assemblyman, police magistrate, county supervisor and alderman and who boasts of his record in filling. Can someone tell me about the tammany hall scandal. But tammany hall s power and control over politics continued, as george plunkitt took the helm and kept the machine at the forefront of new york citys politics through the. Tweed was head of tammany hall, the democratic party political machine that played a major role in the politics of 19th century new york. It was part of the democratic party at the time named after tamanend leader of the lanape a native american tribe.
Profile of george washington plunkitt, tammany hall politican. George washington plunkitt was a sort of middle manager of one of the greatest political machines in u. Riordon, is one of the most famous books of political philosophy ever. Published by signet classic, 1995 isbn 0 451 52620 1 chapter 1, honest graft and dishonest graft. In nyc the political machine was called tammany hall. Plunkitt of tammany hall apush emily cassata 226 chapter 5. Essay about plunkitt of tammany hall 61 words cram. George washington plunkitt of tammany hall everybody is talkin these days about tammany men growin rich on graft, but nobody thinks of drawin the distinction between honest graft and dishonest graft.
Signet classics, new american library, penguin group. Aug 21, 2018 tammany hall was a political force in new york city from its 1789 inception as a benevolent association to mayoral campaigns in the 1950s. But he exercised greater political influence through his work as a ward boss in new yorks fifteenth assembly district. Dec 04, 2015 plunkitt then claims that the difference between a looter and a practical politician is the difference between the philadelphia republican gang and tammany hall. Plunkitt then claims that the difference between a looter and a practical politician is the difference between the philadelphia republican gang and tammany hall. Summary 1 plunkitt of tammany hall nguyen 1 ngan nguyen. Plunkett of tammany hall this volume discloses the mental operations of perhaps the most thoroughly practical politician of the day george washington plunkitt, tammany leader of the fifteenth assembly district, sachem of the tammany society and chairman of the elections. It was so much money that plunkitt wondered why anyone would resort to criminal behavior when there was so much honest graft to be had. Essay about george washington plunkitt of tammany hall. Plunkitt goes on to say that tammany hall is a great big machine, with each part adjusted delicate to do its job. Tammany hall was powerful new york political organization.
One of the famous, albeit not the most important of the oldtime political bosses, was george washington plunkitt. Plunkitt of tammany hall national humanities center. Prepare to be asked quiz questions concerning topics such as political machines, tammany hall, and political party association. But he rose through the ranks of tammany hall by building a following among the workingclass irish of the fifteenth district. Which of the following is not true about tammany hall. George washington plunkitt, honest graft and dishonest graft.
Plunkitt of tammany hall is a great book that shows how a group of openly corrupt politicians can stay in power using a system of apprenticeship and personal favors. Plunkitt served in both houses of the new york state legislature during the late 19th century, but he also operated informally out of the new york city courthouse. Plunkitt of tammany hall essay 1541 words bartleby. Tammany hall, the executive committee of the democratic party in new york city historically exercising political control through the typical bossist blend of charity and patronage. Honest graft and dishonest graft when plunkitt was tipped off about something in the city or someone wanting to built a park or something, he sees the opportunity and he takes it. Plunkitt s arguments against civil service reforms in riordans plunkitt of tammany hall 928 words 4 pages. Dishonest graft involved payoffs for protecting gambling and prostitution. Just think how lovely things would be here if we had a tammany governor and legislature meetin, say in the neighborhood of fiftyninth street, and a tammany mayor and board of aldermen doin business in city hall. Leader of the democratic tammany hall, new york political machine. This volume discloses the mental operations of perhaps the most thoroughly practical politician of the day george washington plunkitt, tammany leader of the fifteenth assembly district, sachem of the tammany society and chairman of the elections committee of tammany hall, who has held the offices of state senator, assemblyman, police magistrate, county supervisor. In one of his speeches, quoted in plunkitt of tammany hall, he describes the difference between dishonest and honest graft.
In the novel plunkitt of tammany hall, author william l. George washington plunkitt, honest graft and dishonest. Plunkitt of tammany hall a series of very plain talks on very practical politics, delivered by exsenator george washington plunkitt, the tammany philosopher, from his rostrum the new york county court house bootblack stand. Chapter five was essentially about the lack of freedom that the government gives the citizens of new york city. George washington plunkitt 18421924 was an influential leader in tammany hall, new yorks democratic political machine. It was the democratic party political machine that played a major role in controlling new york city and new york state politics and helping immigrants. Robert watts ap united states government and politics section 2 professor stephanie guido december 7, 2017 william l. He served as a state senator and a representative to the new york assembly.
Tammany hall primarily worked in a patronage system, which was a factor in engaging new youths to the platform. A series of very plain talks on very practical politics is essentially wha it sounds like. Political bosses were political leaders who got people to vote for them by giving favors. Plunkitt and his political machine tammany hall did some good for the people of new york city the poor gained a much needed friend and political ally. On the other hand, an individual having the power may produce a profound impact on the development of the community and entire society depending on the power he possesses. Riordan, a political reporter for the new york evening post, wrote plunkitt of tammany hall, a book containing the speeches made by george washington plunkitt. Imprisoned for stealing over 100 mill from nyc through political corruption. He lists several examples of the differences, such as the fact that the philadelphia gang runs up. Plunkitt was born in poverty and only received three years of formal education. Plunkitt was a wellliked man among his supporters and tammany men alike. Mar 03, 20 in the novel plunkitt of tammany hall, author william l. Tammany, or the columbian order, was a new york city political organization founded in 1786 and incorporated on may 12, 1789, as the tammany society. It is as important to understanding the united states in the early 20th century as the prince is to understanding the renaissance. Author william riordon describes the fact that the people of ireland and the russian peasants have more freedom than the people of.
Plunkitt helped to awaken politicians to the needs of their constituents and, ultimately, personalized the electorate. Essay about george washington plunkitt of tammany hall bartleby. George washington plunkitt of tammany hall essay the power produces a profound impact on an individual. As justified by washington, he never participated in illegal activities. Honest graft and dishonest graft when plunkitt was tipped off about something in the city or someone wanting to built a park or something, he sees the opportunity and he.
Reform candidates called for an end to political patronage. The term honest graft was coined by george washington plunkitt, a tammany hall boss and political operative. How george washington plunkitt became plunkitt of tammany hall, in plunkitt of tammany hall. But tammany hall s power and control over politics continued, as george plunkitt took the helm and kept the machine at the forefront of new york citys politics through the early twentieth century. This is one of the most famous talks on practical politics by the democratic senator of new york district of tammany, george washington plunkitt, at the beginning of the 20th century. Plunkitt of tammany hall a series of very plain talks on very practical politics william l. My signet classics edition includes an introduction by peter quinn, and amazon has a newer edition which includes a new afterword from phillip freeman, but the bulk of the brief books chapters are talks by george washington. Plunkitt s 40 plus years as a senator, it is also a monument to his enormous ego. Plunkitt of tammany hall 1905 to 6 18651898 gilded age board ap us history primary source. The immigrants relied on tammany hall patronage, particularly for social services. Plunkitts arguments against civil service reforms in riordan. Everybody is talkin these days about tammany men growin rich on graft, but nobody thinks of drawin the distinction between honest graft and dishonest graft. George washington plunkitt of tammany hall, new yorks democratic political machine, distinguished between honest and dishonest graft.
Nov 25, 2016 i thought of plunkitta leader of new yorks democratic political machine, tammany hall, in the late 19th centuryas i read the transcript of trumps fascinating, rambling conversation. Riordan nobody thinks of drawin the distinction between honest graft and dishonest graft. The plunkitt of tammany hall was an insight of street politics in new york published in 1905. Tammany hall boss who defended actions such as honest graft. Riordon, plunkitts political reporter who records the many lectures plunkitt presented at tammany hall. The organization reached a peak of notoriety in the decade following the civil war, when it harbored the ring, the corrupted political organization of boss tweed. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Plunkitt was part of the tammany hall political machine in new york.
Honest graft might involve buying up land scheduled for purchase by government. Riordons purpose is to educate people about politics and to stimulate reform in their corrupt political system. Jul 27, 2019 plunkitt became a power broker within tammany hall, and for nearly 40 years was the undisputed boss of the 15th assembly district, a heavily irish bastion on manhattans west side. He then goes on about how well run tammany is, and concludes by saying that these fool critics dont know what theyre talkin about when they criticize tammany hall, the most perfect political machine on earth. George washington plunkitt was a highranking member of the tammany hall machine, and the author, william riordan, created the book as a series of articles gleaned from mr. Many of its traditions were deeply rooted in an american identity, but essentially what they were able to do was create an identity of their own.
Tweed was head of tammany hall, the democratic party political machine that played a major. In plunkitt of tammany hall, plunkitt bluntly lays out the political philosophy that governed his actions in politics as well as the actions of the infamous tammany hall. Plunkitt also acquired considerable personal wealth by trading his political support for information. He worked his way up from being a helping hand around the district headquarters as a boy, all the way up to being a district leader and a state senator. George washington plunkitt of tammany hall essay example. It was the democratic party political machine that played a major role in controlling new york city and new york state. Mar 21, 2014 plunkitt quickly removes all doubt as to who he believes is fit to govern as he expresses his fondest dream. A series of very plain talks on very practical politics, ed. Starting around 1900, however, people power started to take apart political machines such as tammany hall. Sep 01, 2001 plunkitt, george washington, 18421924. With this sentence in the first chapter plunkitt sets the tone for his short treatise on new york city politics while tammany hall ran the show. A series of very palin talks on very practical politics, with an introduction by peter quinn. Political bosses american history i and psychologysociology.
It became synonymous with bigcity government corruption during the period of. The book emphasizes on plunkitts advocacy for political control and the political machine that helped him gain wealth and a political seat in tammany hall. We can summarize plunkitt s political philosophy into two key areas. The book is a brave explanation on the differences between what was called honest graft and dishonest graft by george washington plunkitt.
79 215 1433 655 1377 1161 67 1119 1142 1503 793 450 1192 1631 425 335 1195 1567 974 1271 1004 1069 153 134 41 1142 1404